Dialog Teologic XXVII/54 (2024)

Dialog Teologic XXVII/54 (2024)
170 p., 17×24, ISSN 1453-8075, 25 lei.
DOI: https://doi.org/10.53438/NYEQ3911
Cumpără online de la Librăria Sapientia
Vizualizează online Dialog 54
Cristian BÎRNAT
Dialog 54-1 Bîrnat Justification in the New Testament writings
Recognizing our sinful nature, the New Testament presents justification as a divine act of grace. Through faith in Christ, we are freed from the bondage of sin and receive a new life, a gift that we can never earn or deserve. This article is structured in three parts, as it emerges from the New Testament writings: in the first part, we will dwell first on the Gospels. Then we will present at length the Apostle Paul’s conception of justification. And finally, we will place alongside the doctrine of Saint Paul and the one emphasized in the Letter of St. James the Apostle.
Gabriel-Iulian ROBU
L’idolo, l’icona e la donazione nella visione di Jean-Luc Marion
The approach with which Marion approaches Thomas’s Aquinas theology at the beginning of his phenomenological journey bears the imprint of Heidegger’s critique of onto-theology, but also of his personal hostility to the conceptual idolatry and atheism manifested in Nietzsche’s philosophy. What Marion contrasts with the conceptual idol is the icon and iconic thought. If the idol comes from looking at it, the icon looks at us, calls forth the vision, letting the visible become saturated with the Invisible. According to Marion, conceptual idolatry still seems a dangerous temptation in our times. Metaphysical categories, concepts can function as idols if they are generated by thought as objects appropriate to ‘God’ on the basis of its divine founding function.
Ionut Eremia IMBRISCA
L’apostolo Paolo: un buon “compagno di viaggio” per Martini
In this article, I would like to present how Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini considered the Apostle Paul a good ‘travel companion’, to come closer to Christ and to live with Him, in facing trials and on the way to the magis. The experience of weakness leads Paul to a greater trust in the presence of the Lord who works with the power of grace in his life and consoles him in tribulations and suffering. By walking the path of weakness, Paul grows in the awareness of his participation in Christ’s death and resurrection. The difficulties that Cardinal Carlo Maria Martini experiences in his life lead him to greater trust in God to the point of abandoning himself in the hands of the Lord, as he is increasingly aware that power comes from the hands of God.
Valerian Sergiu TOPALĂ
Libre arbitre et déterminisme. Un plaidoyer pour le libertarisme agent-causal
In this article we aim to offer a plea for agent-causal libertarianism. This topic will be addressed in the context of the contemporary debate on free will and determinism. The importance of this millennial philosophical-scientific debate is obvious. If our constitution includes a physical nature, like the other elements of material Universe, then it too appears to be governed by the same physical laws. In this case, if the world is deterministic, “(i) all the laws of nature have this feature—they always specify a unique outcome for a given set of initial conditions—and (ii) everything that happens in the Universe falls under some laws of nature or other” Therefore, if this were the case, it seems that we do not possess the freedom we believe we have when we think that we could have done differently in the past, that our present choices are real, and that the future is still open. Since the world was characterized by certain conditions in the distant past, there seems to be only one way it can be today, tomorrow, and forever. Everything in this world seems to be already established, so that our freedom is, at best, an illusion. The illusion becomes even greater when certain findings in neuroscience seem to confirm it. If that were the case, then the stakes of this debate are ones of the highest possible, because by implication, with the illusion of freedom, everything becomes an illusion. Without freedom of the will, not only moral responsibility (with justice systems, religion etc.) and epistemic responsibility become an illusion, but even rationality itself, with all its deliberative and analytical processes, and with it, the knowledge of truth, the possibility of correcting errors of thought and finally the agent itself. The implications are catastrophic for such a world, since in it there is no room for good and evil, truth and falsehood, wisdom and folly, merit and demerit. With the listing of the implications, of which some are more or less aware, the schism among philosophers and scientists also begins. Our article attempts to provide a plea for agent-causal libertarianism in response to these problems. In doing so, we will first provide a classification of libertarianism in order to frame, define, and distinguish the libertarianism we defend. We will then highlight the incompatibility of agent-causal libertarianism with both determinism and other perspectives that promote event-type causation. Also, to clarify our position and introduce our arguments for the plea, we will compare compatibilism with our perspective. Finally, we will present six arguments in favor of agent-causal libertarianism. In this final section, in the part devoted to the objections to the second argument and the responses to the objections, we will also enter into dialogue with some experiments in neuroscience and experimental studies in the cognitive sciences.
Laurențiu TURBUC
Verso una Chiesa vulnerabile? Riflessioni su una categoria fondamentale
The concept of “vulnerability” has gained increasing relevance across multiple disciplines, becoming a key framework for understanding the human condition in all its complexity. This paper explores the etymological and semantic roots of the term before briefly examining its significance from anthropological, philosophical, and biblical perspectives. It analyzes how vulnerability is not merely a state of fragility but also a resource that strengthens relationships and mutual responsibility. The reflection extends to moral theology and canon law, particularly concerning the issue of “vulnerable adults” and the Church’s response to abuse. Finally, it proposes an ecclesiology of vulnerability as a key to authentic ecclesial renewal, capable of overcoming clericalist tendencies and fostering a more welcoming, transparent, and just community.
Gabriel-Iulian ROBU
Sursum corda – la speranza e la fede negli scritti di Andrei Pleșu
According to the Romanian writer Andrei Pleșu, the attitude demanded of Christian faith is one of both hope and audacity, fortified by an awareness of the transcendence of the One who is semper maior. Ethically and aspirationally, we are called to strive for the impossible, with the certainty that in this noble endeavor, we are guided and upheld by a higher authority, God. In this dynamic struggle of hope and faith – charged with vitality and tension – God Himself accompanies us. He challenges us, elevates us, tests us, and sustains us, all within the scope of a singular and harmonious plan of salvation. In this journey, sursum corda is not merely a moral imperative or a call to adopt an optimistic view of life. In the life of faith, “lift up your hearts” is rather „an axiom of cognitive effort, a profound methodological principle”.
Fabian DOBOȘ
Storia della residenza della Diocesi Romano-Cattolica di Bacău (1607-1818)
The article explores the history of the Diocese of Bacău and its bishop’s residence. A marble monument, located in the north-western part of the city of Bacău, and built in 2000 by the Diocese of Iași, summarizes – with its references – the historical memory of the existence of the Diocese of Bacău and serves as the starting point for this historical study. The beginnings and almost the entire existence of the Diocese of Bacău are linked to the monastery of the Franciscan Observants Friars of Șumuleu-Ciuc. Their church became the cathedral of the diocese and the monastery the residence for the bishop.
The bishops who led the Moldavian diocese – most of them of Polish origin – had a difficult life for various reasons: conflicts with the Franciscans of Șumuleu-Ciuc, political circumstances, the poverty of the country, Turkish incursions, and even the floods of 1676, which caused the destruction of the cathedral and monastery. Four of the bishops – Bernardino Quirini, Gerolamo Arsengo, Valerianus Łubieniecki and Marco Bandini – were buried in the cathedral of the city of Bacău. Unfortunately, nothing remains of the old cathedral, nor of the cemetery that was once around the church. However, various civil and religious documents of the time allow us to reconstruct the history of the Diocese of Bacău and to weave, even with unique details, the picture of the life of the Catholic community in Moldavia at that time.
Lucian PĂULEȚ
„The Church—The Mystical Body of Christ: Friend or Enemy? On Scandals in the Church”
This article deals with the problem of scandals in the Church; however, it does not treat about individual scandals in the Church, no matter how appalling they may be, but about the scandal of scandals: the Church herself is holy but also sinful at the same time. This is not a new topic in ecclesiology, yet in recent studies on this paradox, or scandal of the Church, there are divergent points of view. Charles Journet, André de Bovis, Yves Congar, Karl Rahner, Gustave Martelet, and Hans Küng have studied the problem. Despite the divergences, there is a general agreement on several points. This article will show that two points of them are the most important: first, sin cannot be attributed to the Church as such. That is, the subject who sins is not the whole Church but a person or a group of persons. Secondly, the Church, in its constitutive and formal principles, is holy despite the sinfulness of her members. On the institutional level, the Church’s response to sin is through reforms, through which the Church returns to her initial task: holiness. On a personal level, it is helpful to realize that, in spite of the human mistakes of the Church’s members, she is more than a community made of sinners; she is a presence of God, grace, forgiveness, and charity.